Видео

Enel is literally raijin+ Buddha it's not that deep

The saddest part of Sky Island is that the Shandorans probably would have gone through the same but about the gold if they weren't shot up into the sky.

Good job on actually critiquing this show.

Her childhood wonders

Raye is still a girl so use correct grammar her and she.

25:07 Ewwwwwwwww!!! 🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮 That crap is just as bad High Guardian Spice, except High Guardian Spice might be better cause at least you won't lose your lunch from speaking High Guardian Spice's name.

The world is turning into one piece everyday all we missing is the builds and even that's making grounds

19:20 yeah I also love lgtb propaganda in my cartoons, and btw as part of the lgtb community the representation in this show was offensive

i actually really didn’t like jinx at first, but now I realise it’s because she reminds me of myself in so many ways

And addiiontally Jinx is a self fulfilling prophecy

Jinx in S1 has serious abandonment issues which makes sense given her childhood trauma is first losing her parents at an extremely young age and then again losing her family and then her sister outright "abandoning" her after a mistake. Several psychotherapists have commented on her freak out in S1E2 is very much a reflection of the deep seated issues even back then. In that context, Caitlyn or really any threat of being abandoned is absolutely in her head. But then we get the death of Silco. Season 2 strongly implies that when she accepted Jinx in S1E9, she accepted that she's the problem. She is being abandoned because she destroys anything that gets close. Killing Silco was the thing that shifted it. And strangely, it puts her in a calmer place. A more depressed place, but we see only one true bout of psychosis (after Isha is captured) and she doesn't really hate Caitlyn by that point. It's not about Vi choosing between Caitlyn or Jinx, Jinx is unworthy of it. Then she gets Isha, she gets to rebuild part of her family with the return of Vander and starts rebuilding her relationship with Vi. And then Isha dies and Vander goes feral and she's back to her original conclusion: Jinx is a curse. She has only one relationship remaining and that's Vi and she doesn't want to see Vi destroyed so she ends their relationship first. She "frees" Vi of the responsibility of trying to make Jinx loved when Jinx is cursed to never be loved.

I watch this movie every Christmas Eve and it’s beautiful every single year

Is he aldn?

Great commentary! I love your take on Jinx and Vi’s relationship. I think this theme can be pretty well summed up in hallucination Silco’s monologue to Jinx in ep8. The idea that, even though familial love is a powerful force, sometimes it is not enough for the circumstances and all one can do is “walk away” to let things heal. That’s what Jinx realizes and, although she initially sees this as a “I’m just gonna die then”, it’s Ekko who convinces her that she does not need to die to start over that she can “start something new”. I honestly wish Riot would have made it more clear that Jinx lived that way the message would itself be more clear.

brah... lol

I found it sooo hard to hate her because she's just too cool

He's just autistic yall. Don't be mean, call his parents.

His talk with Ambessa in ep 8 really fucked his whole character. It was so annoying. Because he tells her that making dead robots was"always his plan". When act 2 showed a complex arc that took him from "I'd rather go powerless than sacrifice humanity" to"These actions have shown me that humanity is wrong" Almost as if act 3 did not watch act 2 Also I do not believe Viktor would ever side with a warmongerer.

Amazing video quality, dude!Especially the mic quality and your analysis. Hope this video will blow up🎉

Personally. I think people are too hard on LoL Victor. He wants to produce machines to help people survive zaunn. He developed blitzcrank with that very idea in mind since i believe it was a rescue robot, hence grab hand and turbo speed. Victors entire thing is devolping robotic prosthetics to replace parts that are easily damaged in zaun like iron lungs to combat the rampant pollution.

commenting for algo, peak content <3

Before finishing the video, as someone who liked Viktor and his lore before Arcane, I think Viktors lore had more to it and Arcane kinda sacrificed that in favour of Jayce. Viktor starts his work as a child, not with Singed, but by improving the factories in Zaun, with the goal and succiding in reducing the frequent accidents that happened in them to near zero and along with that the casualties and deaths. Viktor also doesn't experiment on himself because he's dying, he does it because he believes he can't expect others to trust him, if he doesn't show it work on himself. The concept of the glorious evolution comes from the idea if you could have your body and mind work better why wouldn't you? Viktor helped and saved countless people. While there's more to it, the main change is that in his og lore, while his ideas were flawed and a lot of people would disagree with them, there was sound logic behind them and you could argue for his case. They made Viktors glorious evolution just clearly, classically bad with creating effectively drones out of people at his command and remove any of the real discussion of his character and beliefs.

hey man love your analysis, hope you do one for the entire cast especially my girl Jinx

This video deserves way more recognition. Amazing work.

amazing vid dude!

Me and a friend are watching this when do edibles. It's not a bad show, but it's not good. It's very passable and Raye with others fessed up that micromanagement is what killed HGS. I'm 4 episodes in and just okay, so far, but if season two was made, I'd watch it

I got your video recommended to me and was expecting for it to have thousands of views. Much to my surprise, you’re actually quite underrated. I love the way you analyse these characters! The editing looks extremely professional too and I love the moments where you crush over Ambessa hahaha it’s hilarious. You’ve earned a new sub.

Quick note: I made a wrong assumption that Mel was Ambessa's adopted daughter. Must've misread the text 😅

What makes you think mel is adopted??

This animation went hard tho

good video 👍

Well i'm eighteen and still watching this show since it came out

"Why arr you here." Missed a pun

What I find so interesting about listening to people try to talk about one piece and politics is that there is so much nuance in this work, there are so many different examples of essentially whatever you want to find. Even among the Celestial Dragons, you can find people who are genuinely good and well-meaning. Personally, I try to look at all fictional stories as explorations of ideas rather than explicit political statements. I do this because, while admittedly not super good at it, I really enjoyed my hand at fictional writing when I was younger, and one of the joys of it was the freedom to explore ideas without any real limit or consequence. You could have read some of my stories and walk away with assumptions about me that were completely opposite to the truth. Just like an actor reveling in playing a villain, or someone taking the Evil route in an RPG that allows for such things. In that regard, I genuinely don't care what Oda's actual politics are. He has written a story that has incredible diversity when it comes to themes, references, and exploration of characters, and ideas. You could say that Oda is anti-authoritarian, but then you'd have to explain all the good representations of monarchs and leaders. You could argue that he advocates for peaceful solutions and is against war, but then you'd have to explain how essentially every conflict is solved by punching the bad guys into submission. You could say that he's in favor of royal lineage, but then you have to contend with how Dalton was essentially forced by the population to become leader of the Sakura kingdom. You have emphasis on genetic lineage and genetic familial bonds, but you also have emphasis on the opposite. You have scenes showing how easy it is for members of an oppressed group to themselves become the oppressors, or even vice versa. He's playing all over the place with the concept of inherent danger. It might be easy to quote Tom and say "just existing is not a sin" but you have to pair that with the reality of the destruction and misery caused by the weapons Franky created. That's just an example, as that topic alone has so much nuance and complexity you could probably write a whole essay on it. The whole story around Skypiea and Shandora and especially the story of Noland and Calgara is filled to the brim with examinations around the ideas of science vs religion vs culture. The numerous ways you can interpret that whole thing can lead you to so many different conclusions. Then there's the whole thing about the marines. It's the one area where you could argue that there's more of a clear direction, but I'd argue that's because the main characters are literally outlaws. The thing is there are plenty of examples of good and even great marines, and they and their sacrifices often go unnoticed and without fanfare in favor of the more bombastic ones that are usually of the less good variety. Because while the system is indeed corrupt at the top, there is also acknowledgement and examination of the idea that justice is different for everyone. Many join the marines with the wish to do good for the world, and while we don't directly see much of it (because our main cast is literally antagonists to the marines) it's still there. The marines sent several battleships to free Cocoyashi village, even with Nezumi there trying to quiet things down. Most of the men under Morgan were actually good, earnest people, as can be seen once Morgan was defeated. Most pirates are genuinely ruthless people who do horrible things, and the marines do put a stop to many of them. It's easy to forget, but Buggy basically razed an entire town for his own amusement and had no issues killing people. The Judge in the backstory of Water7 was genuinely going to pardon Tom for aiding the world's most notorious villain, according to the propaganda because of his service to the community and the government itself. Sometimes it's easy to forget just how vast the One Piece world is, just how many different people live there and how many different things are going on all the time. If you read One Piece and see a clear and obvious political message, I invite you to genuinely examine and challenge your own world view, and pay extra attention to things that you tend to disregard. On that note, I want to mention that I did actively disregard a lot of things that are already often mentioned, especially around just how corrupt the world government is, and the atrocities committed by the marines, but I felt it needed to highlight just some of the things that are often overlooked in order to show the staggering amount of nuance and complexity that actually exist in this story.

To be fair if you landed on any continent and asked "Who owns this?" and their response is "What is ownership?" Yeah it's pretty much free for the taking.

This is one of the best video essays I have seen on Song Of The Sea I really loved how you went so in depth but kept it simple at the same time. It was very well done and it perfectly encapsulates what I love about the movie I especially agree that the simplicity of the movie is one of its strong sides. (Also Saoirse is hard to say out loud and Speak huh XD) Anyways good job and good luck on the youtube game!

What in the hell, why is this video doing so poorly, it's great! How absolutely strange. I just found your channel after the Infinity train episode you did from a couple years back. I liked it. I like those too. Thank you

If it were not for pirates, the marines would not be needed. If it were not for marines, the pirates would not be needed.

But frfr this was great, subscribed.

I don’t think anyone calls them “the pirateerees” anymore lol but I know who you mean

Wait did you just take mugiwara no goofy’s nickname crackhead for luffy?

it says a lot that the biggest contender for main villain in the story is the absolute ruler of the world who is not a sneering, moustache twirling villain who hurts peopel for fun but a cold, reclusive figure who's not even seen as a human but is treated more like a god by those in the know who doesn't simply CARE about the people they rule over.

41:25 yes because when people say politics they dont mean kings queens, soldiers, mayors ruling class, poverty etc and you know that and who people hate is the disingenuous and the token usage of minorities to cover the lack of competency of the writer, who made the entire point the "politics" and every thing else is second, and its added in such a way that causes the product to be worse example your video, every thing you said was well researched and well implemented the points are easy to understand and able to be expanded then at the end you had to add the real life "politics" of hey a black person in a movie is not bad yes every body knows that and no one is against that the problem is not politics is "politics" and you know the difference, and your video flow had to come to a screaming halt because you wanted to add that, now did this make this video bad, no, but it did make it worse now a good example is this video as well the palestine part even if some one has a different opinion over the conflict in this video it was implemented well and even more what side you are on does not matter because the point is the erasure of information wow you did "politics" well and bad in the same video and i hope this explains what is the problem

i love one piece as a palestinian, he frees Palestine like 10 times

FINALLY FINALLY SOMEONE TALKING ABOUT THE HEAVY POLITICS OF ONE PIECEEEE. It’s so overlooked to the point I feel like no one ever takes it seriously.

The easiest way to summarise One Piece is anti authoritarian. Is your goal sunshine and puppies? Doesn't really matter if you're oppressing people to get there. The communist oppresses the bourgeoisie. Luffy isn't against the bourgeoisie, just the ones who abuse their power. The zealot oppresses the unbeliever. Luffy doesn't care about your beliefs, just that they don't trample on others. What he values is in fact, what he identifies with, is a will for freedom. Strive to be free and protect the freedom of others, you have Luffy's fist

The police are coming with a battering ram. Oh no! Run Captain Crackhead! Get your crew of lunatics out of there!

2:45 TOTALLY SPIES MENTIONED!?!?!?!?!